-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 1
/
riskrankingcriteria2024.txt
113 lines (113 loc) · 9.55 KB
/
riskrankingcriteria2024.txt
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
Risk Element|Risk Ranking|Risk Ranking Criteria
Assessment performance | Low | Assessment model(s) passed peer review, high data quality
Assessment performance | Low-Moderate | Assessment passed peer review but some key data and/or reference points may be lacking
Assessment performance | Moderate-High | *This category not used*
Assessment performance | High | Assessment failed peer review or no assessment, data-limited tools applied
F status | Low | F < Fmsy
F status | Low-Moderate | Unknown, but weight of evidence indicates low overfishing risk
F status | Moderate-High | Unknown status
F status | High | F > Fmsy
B status | Low | B > Bmsy
B status | Low-Moderate | Bmsy > B > 0.5 Bmsy, or unknown, but weight of evidence indicates low risk
B status | Moderate-High | Unknown status
B status | High | B < 0.5 Bmsy
Food web (Prey availability) | Low | TBD
Food web (Prey availability) | Low-Moderate | TBD
Food web (Prey availability) | Moderate-High | TBD
Food web (Prey availability) | High | TBD
Food web (Predation pressure) | Low | TBD
Food web (Predation pressure) | Low-Moderate | TBD
Food web (Predation pressure) | Moderate-High | TBD
Food web (Predation pressure) | High | TBD
Food web (Protected species prey) | Low | Few interactions with any protected species
Food web (Protected species prey) | Low-Moderate | Important prey of 1-2 protected species, or important prey of 3 or more protected species with management consideration of interaction
Food web (Protected species prey) | Moderate-High | Important prey of 3 or more protected species
Food web (Protected species prey) | High | Managed species is sole prey for a protected species
Ecosystem productivity | Low | No trends in ecosystem productivity
Ecosystem productivity | Low-Moderate | Trend in ecosystem productivity (1-2 measures, increase or decrease)
Ecosystem productivity | Moderate-High | Trend in ecosystem productivity (3+ measures, increase or decrease)
Ecosystem productivity | High | Decreasing trend in ecosystem productivity, 4+ measures
Climate | Low | Low climate vulnerability ranking
Climate | Low-Moderate | Moderate climate vulnerability ranking
Climate | Moderate-High | High climate vulnerability ranking
Climate | High | Very high climate vulnerability ranking
Distribution shifts | Low | Low potential for distribution shifts
Distribution shifts | Low-Moderate | Moderate potential for distribution shifts
Distribution shifts | Moderate-High | High potential and observed distribution shifts
Distribution shifts | High | Very high potential and observed distribution shifts
Estuarine habitat | Low | Not dependent on nearshore coastal or estuarine habitat
Estuarine habitat | Low-Moderate | Estuarine dependent, estuarine condition stable
Estuarine habitat | Moderate-High | Estuarine dependent, estuarine condition fair
Estuarine habitat | High | Estuarine dependent, estuarine condition poor
Offshore habitat | Low | TBD
Offshore habitat | Low-Moderate | TBD
Offshore habitat | Moderate-High | TBD
Offshore habitat | High | TBD
Commercial value | Low | No trend and low variability in revenue
Commercial value | Low-Moderate | Increasing or high variability in revenue
Commercial value | Moderate-High | Significant long term revenue decrease
Commercial value | High | Significant recent decrease in revenue
Recreational angler days/trips | Low | No trends in angler trips
Recreational angler days/trips | Low-Moderate | Increasing or high variability in angler trips
Recreational angler days/trips | Moderate-High | Significant long term decreases in angler trips
Recreational angler days/trips | High | Significant recent decreases in angler trips
Commercial fishery resilience (Revenue diversity) | Low | No trend in diversity measure
Commercial fishery resilience (Revenue diversity) | Low-Moderate | Increasing or high variability in diversity measure
Commercial fishery resilience (Revenue diversity) | Moderate-High | Significant long term downward trend in diversity measure
Commercial fishery resilience (Revenue diversity) | High | Significant recent downward trend in diversity measure
Commercial fishery resilience (Shoreside support) | Low | No trend in shoreside support businesses
Commercial fishery resilience (Shoreside support) | Low-Moderate | Increasing or high variability in shoreside support businesses
Commercial fishery resilience (Shoreside support) | Moderate-High | Significant recent decrease in one measure of shoreside support businesses
Commercial fishery resilience (Shoreside support) | High | Significant recent decrease in multiple measures of shoreside support businesses
Commercial fishery resilience (Fleet diversity) | Low | No trend in diversity measure
Commercial fishery resilience (Fleet diversity) | Low-Moderate | Increasing or high variability in diversity measure
Commercial fishery resilience (Fleet diversity) | Moderate-High | Significant long term downward trend in diversity measure
Commercial fishery resilience (Fleet diversity) | High | Significant recent downward trend in diversity measure
Recreational fleet diversity | Low | TBD
Recreational fleet diversity | Low-Moderate | TBD
Recreational fleet diversity | Moderate-High | TBD
Recreational fleet diversity | High | TBD
Fishing community vulnerability | Low | Few (<10%) vulnerable fishery dependent communities
Fishing community vulnerability | Low-Moderate | 10-25% of fishery dependent communities with >3 high vulnerability ratings
Fishing community vulnerability | Moderate-High | 25-50% of fishery dependent communities with >3 high vulnerability ratings
Fishing community vulnerability | High | Majority (>50%) of fishery dependent communities with >3 high vulnerability ratings
Commercial fishing production | Low | No trend or increase in seafood landings
Commercial fishing production | Low-Moderate | Increasing or high variability in seafood landings
Commercial fishing production | Moderate-High | Significant long term decrease in seafood landings
Commercial fishing production | High | Significant recent decrease in seafood landings
Recreational fishing production | Low | No trend or increase in recreational landings
Recreational fishing production | Low-Moderate | Increasing or high variability in recreational landings
Recreational fishing production | Moderate-High | Significant long term decrease in recreational landings
Recreational fishing production | High | Significant recent decrease in recreational landings
F Control | Low | No recent history (last 5 years) of overages
F Control | Low-Moderate | Small recent overages, but infrequent
F Control | Moderate-High | Routine recent overages, but small to moderate
F Control | High | Routine recent significant overages
Tech Interactions | Low | No interactions with non-MAFMC managed species
Tech Interactions | Low-Moderate | Interactions with non-MAFMC managed species but infrequent, Category II fishery under MMPA; or AMs not likely triggered
Tech Interactions | Moderate-High | AMs in non-MAFMC managed species may be triggered; or Category I fishery under MMPA (but takes less than PBR)
Tech Interactions | High | AMs in non-MAFMC managed species triggered; or Category I fishery under MMPA and takes above PBR
Offshore wind (Bio/Ecosystem) | Low | TBD
Offshore wind (Bio/Ecosystem) | Low-Moderate | TBD
Offshore wind (Bio/Ecosystem) | Moderate-High | TBD
Offshore wind (Bio/Ecosystem) | High | TBD
Offshore wind (Science/Access) | Low | TBD
Offshore wind (Science/Access) | Low-Moderate | TBD
Offshore wind (Science/Access) | Moderate-High | TBD
Offshore wind (Science/Access) | High | TBD
Other ocean activities | Low | TBD
Other ocean activities | Low-Moderate | TBD
Other ocean activities | Moderate-High | TBD
Other ocean activities | High | TBD
Regulatory complexity | Low | Simple/few regulations; rarely if ever change; same recreational regs across all states
Regulatory complexity | Low-Moderate | Low-moderate complexity; occasional recent changes; few (1-2) recreational regulation differences across states
Regulatory complexity | Moderate-High | Moderate-high complexity; occasional recent changes; moderate (3-4) recreational regulation differences across states
Regulatory complexity | High | High complexity; frequent recent changes; many (5+) recreational regulation differences across states
Discards | Low | No significant discards or incidental catch; no significant discard mortality
Discards | Low-Moderate | Low or episodic discards and incidental catch; low discard mortality
Discards | Moderate-High | Regular discards and incidental catch but managed; moderate discard mortality
Discards | High | High discards and incidental catch, difficult to manage; high discard mortality
Allocation | Low | No recent or ongoing Council discussion about allocation
Allocation | Low-Moderate | *This category not used*
Allocation | Moderate-High | *This category not used*
Allocation | High | Recent or ongoing Council discussion about allocation