Standard shops / POIs not being shown when "3D Buildings" is disabled

[rjw62]

It seems that some standard shops are not being included/shown on the map, probably because of some other tags they do/don't possess.

In particular, most of the shops in the shopping mall in Peterbrough (UK) are not showing up on the most recent Organic Maps maps: https://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=18/52.57368/-0.24446

The shops are mapped as polygons (ways), such as

• https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/660541618
• https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/660541612
• https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/687048117

I would expect a recognised shop=* object to be shown on the map regardless of any other tagging. I'm guessing that it may be the building:part=yes tags that are keeping these shops off the map.

OrganicMaps version: 2024.06.02-12-Google on a Galaxy S10e phone running Android 12.

[dvdmrtnz]

They are showing up just fine for me:

[rjw62]

Thanks. It seems that the difference is whether or not the OrganicMaps "3D Buildings" setting is turned on.

With "3D Buildings" on, I do indeed see those shops, as in the screenshot from @dvdmrtnz . But with "3D Buildings" off, they do not show up (as per my original screenshot).

So it looks like this is some sort of bug, just not quite the cause I was expecting...

[dvdmrtnz]

You’re right, they disappear when 3D Buildings setting is disabled

[RedAuburn]

hmm, maybe because they're also tagged as building:part?

[hoizan]

Similar to #8258

[RedAuburn]

those have building:part too. i guess building:parts are discarded when disabling 3d buildings in order to improve performance, but as a result the amenity/shops are discarded too