Atomkraft with provenance binary (help needed)

[llama-del-rey]

Hi there,

Trying to setup atomkraft to run with the provenance binary. I have tried few different things but not getting past the following error:

👉  atomkraft init provenance-e2e
👉 cd provenance-e2e
👉 atomkraft chain testnet
node id: 655ea20acf1ad2c8db56b1874f3142892375d9b0
Using mainnet defaults
Genesis file created: .atomkraft/validator_nodes/val_q312_lth/node_0/config/genesis.json
Writing app config to: .atomkraft/validator_nodes/val_q312_lth/node_0/config/app.toml ... Done.
Writing tendermint config to: .atomkraft/validator_nodes/val_q312_lth/node_0/config/config.toml ... Done.
Writing client config to: .atomkraft/validator_nodes/val_q312_lth/node_0/config/client.toml ... Done.
Expecting value: line 1 column 1 (char 0)
Exit: 1

chain.toml looks like this:

chain_id = "testnet"
validators = 3
accounts = 2
binary = "../provenance/build/provenanced"
hrp_prefix = "provenance"
denom = "hash"
coin_type = 505

[config_node.app]
minimum-gas-prices = "1905hash"
api = { enable = true, swagger = true, enabled-unsafe-cors = true }
rosetta = { enable = false }

[config_node.config]
instrumentation = { prometheus = false }
p2p = { addr_book_strict = false, allow_duplicate_ip = true }

[config_genesis.app_state.gov]
voting_params = { voting_period = "600s" }

[config_genesis.app_state.mint]
minter = { inflation = "0.300000000000000000" }

Are there any other logs generated besides above? 😕

[rnbguy]

It looks like provenanced init doesn't generate any JSON output, which was expected on Atomkraft's side.

Anyway, I created a branch for its fix. But looks like the wallet addresses are not matching. I get this error finally.

...
Validators
-----------------------------------------
pb1y5pe60nx2yxv50663ys5yw0a943hu6fvpnzf0l
pb1zc0jpd7wu630h6tpu4qe7l2z3nfqlgd5xq73zu
pb10cwldaae2svl69uvffhmjgfph0nlzct6p9m4qz
Accounts
-----------------------------------------
pb120kuy85e0nvqr4n8d9l22u8e06dj70ef6g0njh
pb12ptlggsgsmf0za5j52uu0fm7axyvytfjc4vtpa
Non-zero return code 1
Error: failed to validate account in genesis: account pb12dwqnqvfumd3cjn6tdef5rdjufqs9wapywpk8l does not have a balance in the genesis state
...

Atomkraft uses the standard key-derivation used in cosmos-SDK. Can you share what is being used at Provenance?

I also created a personal Atomkraft repo for provenance binary - https://github.com/rnbguy/atomkraft-provenance

[llama-del-rey]

Thank you for looking into this.

Atomkraft uses the standard key-derivation used in cosmos-SDK. Can you share what is being used at Provenance?
Provenance uses the same thing.

I did make some progress using the following chain.toml and hardcoding a flag for testnet in provenance.

....
hrp_prefix = "tp"
denom = "nhash"
coin_type = 1

[config_node.app]
minimum-gas-prices = "1905nhash"
...

And I get the following error:

node id: ac96cd5cce97158d7b9b1a9c6dbf9321bb8b31be
Using testnet defaults
Genesis file created: .atomkraft/validator_nodes/val_dl5tl0lh/node_0/config/genesis.json
Writing app config to: .atomkraft/validator_nodes/val_dl5tl0lh/node_0/config/app.toml ... Done.
Writing tendermint config to: .atomkraft/validator_nodes/val_dl5tl0lh/node_0/config/config.toml ... Done.
Writing client config to: .atomkraft/validator_nodes/val_dl5tl0lh/node_0/config/client.toml ... Done.
Error: failed to get address from Keybase: tp1y5pe60nx2yxv50663ys5yw0a943hu6fvjc89d4.info: key not found [cosmos/cosmos-sdk@v0.46.3/crypto/keyring/keyring.go:489], could not use address as bech32 string: invalid Bech32 prefix; expected pb, got tp
Usage:
  provenanced add-genesis-account [address_or_key_name] [coin][,[coin]] [flags]

Examples:
$ provenanced add-genesis-account mykey 10000000hash

Is there anyway to pass in flags to provenance binary during startup e.g. provenanced -t for testnet.

[llama-del-rey]

I pulled your changes and installed the package locally. Reproduced the above error that you got as well. But not sure yet how to go about it

[rnbguy]

Hey, @llama-del-rey 🙂 thanks for reporting the issue 🙌

It was indeed a bug. Looks like Atomkraft was not setting up the custom coin type from chain.toml.

PR is coming 🚀

[llama-del-rey]

@rnbguy Thank you for quick response.

I think this line is also causing issues: https://github.com/informalsystems/atomkraft/blob/dev/atomkraft/chain/node.py#L71

I wonder if python-hdwallet needs to be updated as well since HASH does not exist in symbols.py: https://github.com/meherett/python-hdwallet/blob/master/hdwallet/symbols.py

[rnbguy]

Yes, you're right. I fixed it in the PR 🙂

You can install the fixes directly from Github

pip uninstall atomkraft -y
pip install git+https://github.com/informalsystems/atomkraft@rano/provenance

[llama-del-rey]

Oh nice. I think it worked 🙏

[rnbguy]

Awesome! We will release these patches soon, making them available via pypi directly.

Meanwhile, please reach out to us for any other help 🙂

[llama-del-rey]

Thank you for quick fixes.